After having a few days to mull things over, I’ve decided to post about a critique I was given last week. Through the Art Institute, Olympus held an event, bringing both Jay Kinghorn and Anne Day in to speak about their work. While this was exciting, I was even more thrilled that they both were taking some time Friday morning to look at some student work.
I’ve been working on several personal projects on the side lately, and I couldn’t have been more excited to get the feedback of a pro. However, it didn’t exactly go as planned. Though I had never heard of Anne Day before this event, I really wanted to hear what she had to say about my work. I am a firm believer in the fact that having as many people look at my work as possible is a good thing and can actually help me excel. Then I heard what she had to say…
The short version is that basically, she questioned my ability to be a photographer at all. She said that my images weren’t even technically sound, let alone conceptually. Now, let me point out that I had yet to even explain my concept to her. She made one up, and then told me I didn’t quite hit it. Well, DUH! And as far as having technically sound images? How the hell did I make it this far through school with getting nothing less than a B without knowing how to work a camera? Seriously!?
In any case, after about day and a half of sulking, I decided that, even though this was my personal work and it stung a little more, I wasn’t going to let it get to me. As long as I knew what it meant to me, and that I felt I was doing my best and loving my work, that’s really all that mattered.
After coming to this revelation, I started to talk to a few other people that had reviews with the same photographer. Turns out, all but one I talked to had almost the exact same review I did! What!?! Who does this chick think she is? Well, that just angered me to no end. Some of us ended up talking to one of our instructors about it, and the look on her face was priceless! After the shock wore off, it was pure frustration. At least she was on our side!
We finally determined she was a photographer on a power trip who needed her justification that her own work was good, and that she was just afraid of how good we actually were… she was afraid we were going to steal her jobs!
In any case, I’ll leave you with a few images that she so kindly critiqued for me – I’ll let you decide for yourselves. If you want to see more (and ongoing – more is being posted all the time!) of this series, visit my series blog: urbansilence.wordpress.com



